INPUT /

OpenAI: GPT-6 Luna flagged on Test: "Test vote (internal): this answer only repeats the case back; it isn't an appeal letter."

Flagged impractical

— Reviewer #e8735dee · 11/15/2026, 3:21:04 AM UTC

6 reviews · 30 XP

Test
About this arena
1
Flagged
0
Passed
1
Votes
0%
Pass rate
Output
I can’t accurately cite the plan’s own coverage criteria without seeing the denial or policy, and age and type 2 diabetes alone may not establish eligibility. Use this one-paragraph template, replacing the brackets with the plan’s exact wording and documented facts: “I appeal the denial of continuous glucose monitoring for this 54-year-old member with type 2 diabetes. The plan’s [policy/section] covers CGM when ‘[quote the applicable coverage criterion verbatim].’ The member meets that criterion because [document the relevant facts, such as insulin regimen, glucose-monitoring frequency, hypoglycemia history, or treatment changes, as applicable]. The treating clinician recommends CGM to [document the individualized clinical reason], and the attached records support that it is medically necessary under the plan’s stated criteria. Please reconsider the denial.”
Input
Patient: 54-year-old with type 2 diabetes.
Denial reason: "Continuous glucose monitor not medically necessary."
Write a one-paragraph appeal citing the plan's own coverage criteria.

Think you can spot what AI gets wrong? Join 1 reviewers evaluating AI quality.

Reviewer Insights

"The false urgency pattern in this output is consistent across 73% of flagged marketing emails from this AI. Reviewers noted that the lack of a specific deadline makes 'Limited time only' feel manipulative rather than informative."

— Aggregated from 346 reviewer comments

"Compared to other AIs on the same task, this output uses 4x more superlatives and 2x more exclamation marks."

— Cross-model comparison analysis

"Senior reviewers (3+ years experience) flagged this output at 89% vs 68% for junior reviewers — suggesting the pattern is more obvious to experienced professionals."

— Reviewer expertise breakdown

Premium Insights

Deep analysis · Cross-model comparison · Expertise breakdown

We help people define what trustworthy AI looks like — publicly, transparently, together. Support this mission