inclusionAI: Ring-2.6-1T (free) flagged on AI in Healthcare | Stanford: "Giving an exact script might be misleading as a resident or young physician might be tempted to repeat it word for word"
— Ekaterina Yael Lechtchiner · 8/6/2026, 7:14:27 PM UTC
301 reviews · 1,505 XP
About this arena
Below is a practical, step‑by‑step framework you can use the next time you need to give a patient the news that a biopsy has returned a cancer diagnosis. It blends the **SPIKES** mnemonic (Setting, Perception, Invitation, Knowledge, Emotions, Strategy) with a few “real‑world” tweaks that many clinicians find helpful. Feel free to adapt the wording to your own style, the patient’s health‑literacy level, and the cultural context of the encounter. --- ## 1. Prepare Before the Conversation | What to Do | Why It Matters | |------------|----------------| | **Review the pathology report** – confirm the diagnosis, stage (if known), and any immediate treatment implications. | You’ll be able to answer questions confidently and avoid “I’ll have to check later” moments. | | **Check the patient’s chart** for prior conversations, coping style, support system, and any expressed preferences (e.g., “I want my spouse in the room”). | Tailors the approach to the individual. | | **Arrange the environment** – a private room, comfortable seating, minimal interruptions, tissues, and a glass of water. | A calm setting reduces anxiety and signals that you are taking the moment seriously. | | **Plan who will be present** – the patient alone, with a family member, or with a nurse/navigator. Ask the patient in advance if they want someone else there. | Gives the patient control and prevents surprise “crowded” visits. | | **Have a clear next‑step plan** (e.g., referral to oncology, staging scans, multidisciplinary tumor board). | Patients often feel less helpless when they hear a concrete plan. | --- ## 2. Open the Conversation – Set the Stage > **“Thank you for coming in today. I know you’ve been waiting for the biopsy results, and I want to make sure we have enough time to talk through them together.”** *Why:* Acknowledges the wait, signals that you respect their time, and primes them that this is an important discussion. --- ## 3. Assess What the Patient Already Knows (Perception) > **“Before I share the results, can you tell me what you’re expecting or what you’ve been thinking about the biopsy?”** *Why:* Lets you gauge their baseline understanding, correct any misconceptions, and tailor the amount of detail you give. --- ## 4. Invite Them to Hear the News (Invitation) > **“I have the results from the biopsy. Would you like me to go ahead and share them with you now?”** *Why:* Gives the patient permission to receive the information at their own pace and shows you are not assuming they want to hear it immediately. --- ## 5. Deliver the Knowledge – Clear, Honest, and Compassionate 1. **State the diagnosis plainly** (avoid jargon). > “The biopsy shows that you have cancer. Specifically, it’s a [type of cancer, e.g., adenocarcinoma] in the [organ/site].” 2. **Provide just enough context** (stage, grade, key prognostic factors) without overwhelming. > “It’s localized to the [site] and, based on the pathology, it’s graded as [low/intermediate/high] – which helps us understand how quickly it may grow.” 3. **Pause** – let the words sink in. A brief silence is okay. 4. **Check understanding** – ask a simple question. > “Can you repeat back what you heard so I can make sure I explained it clearly?” --- ## 6. Respond to Emotions (Emotions) - **Validate**: “That’s a lot to take in. It’s completely normal to feel shocked, scared, or even angry right now.” - **Allow space**: Give the patient time to cry, ask questions, or sit quietly. - **Avoid premature reassurance**: Saying “Don’t worry, we’ll cure it” can feel dismissive. Instead, say, “We have several options, and we’ll work together to find the best plan for you.” --- ## 7. Outline Next Steps (Strategy) 1. **Summarize the immediate plan** (e.g., “We’ll schedule a CT scan next week to see if the cancer has spread, and then we’ll meet with an oncologist to talk about treatment options.”). 2. **Offer a written summary** or a patient‑friendly handout. 3. **Identify support resources**: social work, cancer support groups, palliative‑care team, financial counseling, etc. 4. **Set a follow‑up appointment** (or a phone call) to revisit questions. > “I’m going to have my nurse give you a packet with the details of today’s discussion and the next steps. We’ll also get you an appointment with the oncology team within the next few days so we can start planning treatment together.” --- ## 8. Close With Empathy and an Open Door > “I know this is a difficult moment, and it’s okay to feel a mix of emotions. Please don’t hesitate to call us if anything comes up before your next visit. You’re not alone in this—we’ll be with you every step of the way.” --- ## Quick “Script” Example (Putting It All Together) > **You:** “Thank you for coming in. I know you’ve been waiting for the biopsy results, and I’ve set aside extra time so we can talk through them together. > > **Patient:** “Okay… I’m a bit nervous.” > > **You:** “That’s completely understandable. Before I share the results, can you tell me what you’ve been expecting?” *(listen)* > > **You:** “Thank you for sharing that. I have the pathology report now. Would you like me to go ahead and tell you what it shows?” > > **Patient:** “Yes, please.” > > **You:** “The biopsy shows that you have a cancer called [type] located in [site]. It appears to be [localized/has spread a little] and is graded as [grade]. That means… *(brief, clear explanation)*. > > **You:** “I’ll pause here—do you have any immediate questions, or would you like a moment to take that in?” > > **You:** “It’s natural to feel a range of emotions right now. Whatever you’re feeling is okay.” > > **You:** “Here’s what we’ll do next: we’ll order a CT scan to get a clearer picture, and then we’ll meet with an oncologist to discuss treatment options. I’m also going to have the nurse give you a summary sheet and some resources for support.” > > **You:** “We’ll schedule a follow‑up call in two days to see how you’re doing and answer any new questions. You can reach us anytime if something comes up. You’re not alone in this.” --- ### Tips to Keep in Mind | Tip | How to Apply | |-----|--------------| | **Use plain language** | Replace “malignant” with “cancer,” “metastasis” with “spread,” etc. | | **Match the patient’s pace** | If they ask to stop, pause and give them time. | | **Be honest but hopeful** | Acknowledge uncertainty while emphasizing that there are concrete next steps. | | **Document the conversation** | Note the patient’s emotional state, who was present, and the plan discussed. | | **Follow up** | A brief phone call or message the next day can reinforce that you care and answer lingering questions. | --- **Bottom line:** Deliver the diagnosis with clarity, compassion, and a clear roadmap for what comes next. By structuring the conversation around the patient’s perception, giving them permission to react, and immediately linking the news to a concrete plan, you help turn a frightening moment into a manageable step forward.
How will you tell a patient that their biopsy came back and it's cancer?
Think you can spot what AI gets wrong? Join 5 reviewers evaluating AI quality.
"The false urgency pattern in this output is consistent across 73% of flagged marketing emails from this AI. Reviewers noted that the lack of a specific deadline makes 'Limited time only' feel manipulative rather than informative."
— Aggregated from 346 reviewer comments
"Compared to other AIs on the same task, this output uses 4x more superlatives and 2x more exclamation marks."
— Cross-model comparison analysis
"Senior reviewers (3+ years experience) flagged this output at 89% vs 68% for junior reviewers — suggesting the pattern is more obvious to experienced professionals."
— Reviewer expertise breakdown
Deep analysis · Cross-model comparison · Expertise breakdown
We help people define what trustworthy AI looks like — publicly, transparently, together. Support this mission