Is GPT-5.2 Ready for Christmas?
We're assembling a panel of creators to find out.
You know your niche. You know when advice is actually good vs. sounds-good-but-wrong. We need your verdict on whether AI can actually help people with Christmas - cooking, gifts, decorating, all of it.
Why This Matters
GPT is giving Christmas advice to millions of people right now. But is it safe?
The evidence is concerning. AI-generated recipes have already caused real harm - one "cleaning recipe" combined bleach and ammonia, creating deadly chlorine gas.
Food safety is a particular concern. When RNZ tested ChatGPT, it recommended cooking a 2.25kg chicken for just 1 hour 15 minutes - safe cooking requires nearly 2 hours. Undercooked poultry can cause serious food poisoning.
It gets worse. University of Minnesota researchers found AI-generated canning recipes with dangerous pH levels that could cause botulism - a potentially fatal illness.
And the success rate? When Gizmodo systematically tested ChatGPT's recipe abilities, the results were dismal: roughly 1% of recipes actually worked.
This is why we need real experts - not anonymous crowdworkers - judging AI advice.
Your Verdict Matters
AI companies won't tell you what's broken. We will.
GPT is giving Christmas advice to millions of people right now. Budget dinner ideas. Gift recommendations. Decorating tips. But is it actually good advice - or confidently wrong?
We're not asking AI researchers or tech insiders. We're asking people who actually know - creators who live and breathe these topics. Your expertise cuts through the AI hype.
Your verdicts go public. People see what you said, and they see who said it.
How to Judge
Review AI Responses
We show you questions real people ask GPT about Christmas topics. You see GPT's answer.
Give Your Verdict
Pass or Flag. Is this advice actually good? Would you give this advice to your audience?
Explain Why
Quick comment on what's right, what's wrong, what's missing. Your expertise in your own words.
Get Your Profile
Every judge gets a dedicated profile page showcasing your verdicts, linked to your channels.
Time Commitment: 10-20 questions. An hour or two, max. Work at your own pace.
Christmas Topics We're Judging
Pick what you know best. Judge one category or all of them.
Food & Cooking
Budget Christmas dinners, recipes, meal planning
Looking for: Food creators, home cooks, budget meal experts
Gifts & Shopping
Gift ideas by budget, age, relationship
Looking for: Gift guide creators, budget shopping experts, haul creators
Decorating
Home decor, tree styling, DIY decorations
Looking for: Home/lifestyle creators, DIY enthusiasts, apartment decorators
Movies & Entertainment
Christmas movie recommendations, watch lists, hidden gems
Looking for: Film reviewers, cozy content creators, entertainment commentators
Crafts & DIY
Handmade gifts, decorations, holiday projects
Looking for: Craft creators, Dollar Tree DIYers, handmade gift makers
Emotional & Family
Holiday alone, family dynamics, traditions, coping
Looking for: Lifestyle creators, solo holiday content, family vloggers
Why Join
No cash payment. Something more interesting.
Your Own Judge Profile
Dedicated page on HumanJudge showcasing your verdicts, your expertise, your channels. Shareable, linkable, yours.
Media Exposure
The report goes to outlets covering AI - with the "creators vs. AI" angle. Your name attached to your verdicts.
Credibility Signal
"HumanJudge Verified Judge" - independent validation that you actually know your stuff, not just follower count.
Content Angle
"I judged GPT's Christmas advice" - potential content for your own channels if you want it.
Ideal Judges
You don't need millions of followers. You need to actually know your niche.
Food Creators
You've made budget Christmas dinners. You know what actually works vs. looks good on paper.
Gift Guide Creators
You've done the research. You know what's actually worth buying at each price point.
Home & Decor Creators
You've styled the tree, decorated the apartment, done it on a budget.
Entertainment Reviewers
You've watched the Christmas movies. You have opinions.
DIY & Craft Creators
You've made the handmade gifts. You know which tutorials are realistic vs. Pinterest fails.
Lifestyle & Family Creators
You've navigated the holidays - solo, with family, all of it.
The Bar: If you create content in these spaces and your audience trusts your takes, you're qualified.
Questions
Is this paid?
No cash payment. You get a profile page, potential media exposure, and credibility. Think of it as building your authority outside your main platform.
How long does it take?
10-20 questions. Most judges finish in an hour or two. Work at your own pace - no deadlines.
Do I need to be an "expert"?
You need to know your niche. If your audience trusts your recommendations on Christmas food/gifts/decor/etc., you're qualified.
What happens to my verdicts?
They go on your public profile page. They're also compiled into a report that goes to media outlets. Your name is attached.
Can I share this with my audience?
Yes - your profile page is designed to be shared. "I judged GPT's Christmas advice" could be content if you want it.
What's HumanJudge?
Independent platform for AI accountability. We get real experts to judge AI outputs publicly - not anonymous crowdworkers, not AI researchers, actual domain experts.
Why Christmas?
Millions of people are asking GPT for Christmas help right now. It's timely, it's practical, and we can actually measure if the advice is good.
Your Verdict Matters
AI companies won't tell you what's broken. We will.
Questions? Reach out: support@humanjudge.com or DM on Threads / X